Advanced Keyboarding: Alternative Layouts and Specialized Typing

Once you can touch type on QWERTY at a comfortable speed, two kinds of "advanced" practice open up. One is switching to an alternative layout such as Dvorak, Colemak or Workman. The other is getting good at the parts of the keyboard most people avoid: the number row, the numeric keypad, punctuation and the symbols used in code. This guide covers both, with honest notes on what switching layouts costs and how to measure whether any of it is paying off.

Why is QWERTY laid out the way it is?

QWERTY comes from the mechanical typewriters of the 1870s. The arrangement was shaped by the machines and the people using them at the time, not by any study of finger travel on a modern keyboard. The popular story is that it was designed to slow typists down. The more accurate version is that it was tuned to reduce jams in early typewriters, and it then became the standard because everyone had already learned it.

The practical consequence is that QWERTY puts several of the most common English letters away from the home row. E, T, O and N all need a reach, and the home row itself includes rarely used keys like J and the semicolon. That is the gap every alternative layout tries to close.

Dvorak vs Colemak vs Workman: what actually changes?

All three alternatives move common letters onto the home row and try to spread work more evenly between the hands. They differ mainly in how far they depart from QWERTY.

Dvorak is the biggest jump and the hardest to go back from. Colemak is the most popular choice among people switching today, mostly because it keeps the bottom-left shortcut keys and most punctuation where they were. Workman is a smaller niche, aimed at typists who find the reach to the middle columns uncomfortable.

Is switching to Dvorak or Colemak worth it?

For most people, no, and it is worth saying that plainly. Fast typists exist on every layout. People sustain well over 100 WPM on plain QWERTY, and the speed difference between layouts for a trained typist is small compared with the difference made by practice. Barbara Blackburn, listed by Guinness World Records as reaching up to 212 WPM, typed on Dvorak, but that tells you about her, not about the layout.

The better reasons to switch are comfort and interest. Some typists find that less finger travel feels easier on their hands over a long working day, and some simply enjoy the challenge. Reasons not to switch include shared or work computers, frequent use of shortcuts, and games that assume WASD keys. If you type below about 40 WPM on QWERTY, which is roughly the adult average, you will gain far more from learning to touch type properly on the layout you already have.

How long does it take to relearn a keyboard layout?

Expect to start close to zero. Your QWERTY muscle memory does not transfer, so the first week on a new layout feels like being a beginner again. Most people who switch report needing several weeks of daily practice to get back to a usable speed and a few months to match their old pace. Practising only one layout at a time makes the transition much less confusing.

A few practical points if you try it on TypeTails. The typing test reads the characters your keyboard actually produces, so it works with whatever layout your operating system is set to. The on-screen keyboard in the English lessons is drawn as QWERTY, though, so its key highlights will not match a remapped keyboard; follow the text on screen instead. Start from the home row drill in Lesson 1 and expect it to feel slow.

How do you practice number typing and 10-key data entry?

Numbers are where many otherwise fast typists slow to a crawl. On the top row, the usual rule is that each finger moves straight up from its home key: the left index covers 4 and 5, the right index 6 and 7, and so on. Most people learn this late, so they hunt for digits by sight.

For data entry, the numeric keypad is faster. The right hand rests with the index finger on 4, middle on 5 (usually the key with a raised bump) and ring on 6, the thumb takes 0, and the little finger handles Enter. Lesson 12 on numbers and 10-key typing adds an on-screen number pad and mixes in realistic strings like amounts, dates and reference numbers, which is closer to real data entry than random digits.

Why are punctuation and symbols so hard to type quickly?

Punctuation lives on the edges of the keyboard, under the little fingers, and often needs Shift as well. Most typing practice uses lowercase words, so these keys get very little repetition. The result is a pause before every apostrophe, question mark or bracket.

The fix is targeted repetition with real sentences rather than isolated symbols. Punctuation practice in Lesson 13 uses full sentences with commas, periods, question marks and exclamation points, so you learn the keys in the places they actually appear. Use the Shift key on the opposite hand from the letter you are capitalising; it feels awkward at first and saves a lot of strain later.

What should programmers practise beyond normal typing?

Code is dense with brackets, braces, operators and mixed case, and plain prose drills barely touch those keys. Programmers benefit most from short, frequent sessions on symbol-heavy text. TypeTails has a lesson on programming syntax later in the course, and the Console Hack coding typing game turns the same skill into a timed challenge, with command strings, file paths and code fragments full of numbers, dashes and symbols.

How can you tell whether a new layout or drill is working?

Measure the same way every time. Short tests swing a lot from one attempt to the next, so for tracking progress a longer run is more reliable. The 5-minute typing test shows WPM, accuracy, keystrokes per minute and your most-missed keys, and the most-missed list is especially useful after a layout switch because it shows exactly which keys have not settled yet.

Judge accuracy before speed. If you are under about 95% accuracy, slow down until the errors stop. For a sense of where your numbers sit, the guide to typical WPM by age and job gives the usual ranges, from around 40 WPM for the average adult to 75 WPM or more for trained professional typists.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)